Custom Cakes

Custom Cakes

We believe our cakes should be the STAR of the party! Our colorful eye-popping designs are uniquely created for each client. Our cakes are all baked from scratch in small batches using premium ingredients.


Design Process

This process begins when you provide us with your ideas including event details, color palette and theme/occasion. We will then take this inspiration and incorporate it into the overall cake design.

Wandering Whisk will work with you to bring your buttercream dreams to life and create a one-of-a-kind cake.  

We recommend that you book anywhere from two weeks to several months in advance as we only take on a limited number of orders each week.

Base Pricing

6” (12 servings) $125

8” (20 servings) $150

9” (24 servings) $170

10” (28 servings) $195

Two-Tiered (36+ servings) start at $350

Design Add Ons

Fresh Florals

Colored Cake Layers

Sprinkle Explosion

Ganache Drip (Dark or White Chocolate, Salted Caramel)

 Macarons, Fruit, Cookies, Candy, Gold Leaf

*We are a buttercream only bakery & don’t work with fondant.

We have a variety of pre-designed Party Cakes that will make your

ordering process a little easier and are available within a shorter time frame.


Cake Flavor Menu

Banana Nutella

The cake that started

it all! Fresh Banana

Cake layered with Chocolate Ganache & Nutella Buttercream.

Brown Sugar Buttermilk

A cozy cake packed with warm fall spices paired with Cinnamon Buttercream.

Chocolate Chip

Cookie Dough


Chocolate Cake layered with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Buttercream.

Chocolate Sea Salt

Inspired by our popular Cookie Sandwich flavor! Chocolate Cake layered with Salted Caramel Buttercream and a sprinkle of flaky sea salt.


A nostalgic take on our childhood favorite. Vanilla Almond Sprinkle Cake layered with Vanilla Bean Buttercream.

Cookies & Cream

Our Vanilla Bean Cake batter is filled with crushed Oreos and layered with Cookies & Cream Buttercream. Can also swap the Vanilla Bean Cake for Chocolate Cake.

Double Chocolate

A chocolate lover’s dream! Decadent Chocolate Cake layered with either Milk Chocolate or Dark Chocolate Fudge Buttercream. Add a Chocolate Ganache Drip to take it over the top!

Lemon Blueberry

Lemon Cake filled with fresh blueberries and layered with Lemon Buttercream. Add layers of Blueberry Compote to take it to the next level!

Lemon Lavender

One of our most popular wedding flavors! Lemon Cake layered with Lavender Buttercream. Add  in layers of our Lemon Curd to make this a lemon dream.

Orange Passion Fruit

You’ll feel like you’re on a tropical vacation with this Orange Blossom Cake layered with Passion Fruit Buttercream and layers of Passion Fruit Curd.

Peanut Butter Cup Cake

Chocolate Cake layered with silky Peanut Butter Buttercream. Add in crushed Peanut Butter Cups.


A childhood classic in cake form. Peanut Butter Cake layered with Raspberry Jam and Peanut Butter Buttercream.

Pina Colada

As seen on Food Network! Pineapple Coconut Cake layered with Coconut Buttercream.

Raspberries & Cream

Vanilla Bean Cake layered with fresh Raspberry Buttercream.


Chocolate Cake layered with Graham Cracker Buttercream and topped with toasted marshmallow.

Salted Pretzel

Our crunchy Salted Pretzel Cake Layered with Salted Caramel Buttercream

Order Your Custom Cake!


We require at least TWO WEEKS notice for all Custom Cakes.

If you're looking for a cake in a shorter time frame, please visit our Party Cakes page (ADD LINK).

If you do not get a response within 3 business days, please check your spam folder as some of our emails end up there.


(Open by appointment only)

Wandering Whisk Bakeshop

4505 Park Blvd N

Suite 5

Pinellas Park, FL 33781


By Phone: 727-440-5995

By Email: hello@wanderingwhiskbakeshop.com

On social media:

  • Facebook Logo Pink
  • Instagram Logo Pink
  • Twitter Logo Pink